Hours later, a camp counselor found the girls' bodies stuffed in their sleeping bags and scattered through the woods. Dale R. Lewis is the author of "Footprints in the Dew," a book about Chub Anderson, who gained notoriety for his connection to the Mullendore murder case in 1970. In 1996, Ted LaTurner, a private investigator who looked into the case, got a petition approved that had the Mayes County grand jury take a look at some leads he had found. As she headed out of her tent, she spotted what appeared to be sleeping bags a little way away from her tent. 'Gotham Knights' kills Batman and replaces him with moody teens, This Houston rodeo food vendor wants you to eat his rattlesnake. Gene LeRoy Hart, who had been acquitted of murdering three Tulsa-area Girl Scouts at Camp Scott near Locust Grove, died of a heart attack in the state penitentiary. He appealed, received a new trial, and was re-sentenced to serve sixty-years for manslaughter. Houston pitmaster goes viral after hilarious TV interview, 'Call me a Nazi': Former Houston pastor calls for state book ban, Houston facing severe thunderstorms, possible tornadoes Thursday, Former KHOU anchor turns layoff into lucrative real estate career, Houston is in for dust and gray skies as Texas haboob arrives, The only Houston rodeo food guide you'll need, Report: Houston ranked No. A day later, Mr. Freeman was found shot in the head. KANSAS: In 1970, 12-year-old Kelly Lynn Albright went missing and was found dead in a field in Reno County. Among them were Lori Lee Farmer, 8, Doris Denise Milner, 10, and Michele Guse, 9. After decades . had a $15 million life insurance policy on him, with his wife as the beneficiary. She has driven hundreds of thousands of miles in her car that has been wrapped with photos of Brittanyhoping to bring awareness to this decade-long case. Sheri Farmer, Loris mother, established the Oklahoma Parents of Murdered Children and is a strong advocate for victims and their families. On that dreary evening, 8-year-old Lori Lee Farmer, 9-year-old Michelle Heather Guse, and 10-year-old Doris Denise Milner returned to their cabin in the Kiowa Unit. Fast. The killer had swept away footprints and tire tracks. Because of this, he had a vast group of staunch supporters. [5], According to private investigator Gary Glanz, in 2010 Chub Anderson told Glanz that he had killed E.C. the Murderpedia project stay alive. Chester, [], Posted: July 1st, 2013 under Feature Stories. The DNA sample was a semen stain found on a pillowcase inside Michelle Guses sleeping bag. Wilhite would say later that when she was back in her tent trying to fall asleep, she could still hear that sound. As a result of these concerns, Governor Trapp, in his message to the Tenth Oklahoma legislature, recommends the creation of a statewide law enforcement agency. Tags: 1920s, 1930s, Murder, Oklahoma, William Tyson Horton was a serial rapist and child molester from Oklahoma City who operated between 1970 and 2010. DNA found at the crime scene has not matched any of the suspects or any of the other 3,000 samples it has been tested against. He just had a thing for stealing glasses everywhere he went," said Marty Wilson, an OSBI Agent. Mullendore. However, lingering questions remain nearly 45 years later: was Gene Leroy Hart the killer? Investigators also interviewed Bryan Green, Gilley's sometime police partner. The girls were all staying in tent #8 in the camps "Kiowa" unit the most remote tent at the summer camp (a fourth girl was set to join the three campers in tent #8 the next day). However, instead of going to see an eye doctor, Hart developed a habit of stealing glasses. Interestingly enough, Frank Justice was the uncle of Sonny James. Paula, a 44 year-old woman, was shot to death in her home on April 30, 2013. "It was the boogeyman story," said Andrea Fielding, the Director of Forensic Science Services at the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation. Anderson said that ranch hand Lonnie Joe Brown, his brother-in-law, had helped him stage the murder to look like intruders had killed E.C., including shooting Anderson in the arm. There have been three books written about that summer night in 1977, a documentary has been made, and there is a website just for [], Posted: July 16th, 2015 under Rediscovered Crime News. Amateur sleuths and Internet detectives: Now's your chance to prove your skills. No one was ever charged in the crime. Two of the sleeping bags were zipped closed. One of the most mysterious unsolved crimes of the decade was the murders of prominent Oklahoma City residents Syrl Orbach, 87, and his wife, Christine, 67. In the 1970s and 1980s, the division investigated . Solve these real unsolved cases, then alert the police so they can put these babies to bed. The excited campers were blissfully unaware when they walked into camp that their two weeks would end abruptly. need your help for this. On the bus, Denise cried about having to leave. We have many He wrote a note shortly before his death, professing his innocence. While both the effigy and the note were strange and upsetting, the letter also mentioned Martians. Sheryl Benham and Sloan disappeared after they attended a fraternity party May 9, 1970, at the University of Oklahoma. Gilley passed a polygraph. When police arrived on the scene, they found Tent #8 covered in blood. However, he did return to prison for his original crimes, where he died of a heart attack on June 4, 1979, at the age of 35. Sloan clothed. plans and enthusiasm Tags: 1970s, Murder, Oklahoma, . A fourth girl was supposed to stay in the tent with them but wasn't scheduled to arrive until the following day. "Didnt matter if they were mens or womens glasses. Authorities returned him to the Mayes County Jail where he escaped again. Paula's home was located at a busy intersection in Manchester and police believe someone had to have witnessed her murder. Privacy Policy | Terms | Contact | Sitemap True Crime Historian Blog, Celebrated Criminal Cases of America, 1830-1910, Mug Shot Monday! During the day, the three girls had all participated in camp activities and written letters home to their families. Many questions remain unanswered about the events that unfolded prior to, and at the time of the murders. Get more stories delivered right to your email. She was not keen on the idea of leaving her mom Bettye and her 5-year-old sister. However, those familiar with the area or even experienced hunters would know that there were three caves surrounding the camp. Robbery appeared to be the motive. The duct tape and rope both matched the kind used on the three girls. William Tyson Horton was a serial rapist and child molester from Oklahoma City who operated between 1970 and 2010. It was a favorite spot for Girl Scouts to gather and make new friends and create childhood memories. Within months of the murders, Stevens was arrested on similar rape and kidnapping charges. [2], Gene Mullendore handed over management of the ranch to his son in 1960 because of his failing eyesight. TURRENTINE. On the night of September 26, 1970 E.C. 3 Girl Scouts were murdered at camp nearly 45 years ago. slumped on a couch and bleeding. They were found with their throats slashed about 3 p.m. on July 1, 1982. Police are retesting unknown DNA that was found at the crime scene. I think it hit all of them pretty hard," said Wilson, OSBI investigator. Brittany, an 18-year-old college student, was found dead in her Tulsa apartment on September 30, 2004. The trail that passed by the Kiowa Unit also led to the back gate of the camp. After decades . The girls were found bludgeoned, strangled, sexually assaulted and murdered. Around 10 that morning, and without any explanation to the other campers, the camp was evacuated, and the girls were bussed back to Tulsa. He also helped pass the Oklahoma Victims Bill of Rights, to protect the rights of the victims no less vigorous than the rights afforded to the accused. He said that he rushed downstairs and found E.C. For three young girls, their first night of camp would haunt Oklahoma to this day. Summer camp has been a staple of the American experience for generations. Mullendore III (October 26, 1937 September 26, 1970) was an heir to one of the largest cattle ranches in Oklahoma. Contact me here. It was 20 years ago Sunday. HALE, Harold Loyd McELMURRY "Our belief is that Gene Leroy Hart committed the murders," Fielding said. These tragic murders still remain unsolved 40 years later. One camper said they heard a scream in the night and another camper said they heard someone crying for their momma. in a fight after Anderson had helped deputies serve divorce papers on E.C. Wilhite woke early, around 6 a.m., to get a shower before the other campers woke up. Thinking it was most likely an animal,Wilhite went back to sleep. Then, Wilhite and fellow counselor Dee Elder walked over to the Tent Six to get the girls to quiet down. In fact, it would later become known that Wise had made a book deal with a local reporter in exchange for information. Their bodies were pocked with bullet holes. The Mullendore family owned the Cross Bell Ranch in Osage County, Oklahoma, which covered about 130,000 acres. Sloan's 1968 Pontiac GTO was found May 11. Though they assumed it was an animal, when Wilhite went to investigate and shone her flashlight in the direction of the noise, the sound stopped. Mullendore III was born to Eugene Claremont "Gene" Mullendore Jr. and Kathleen (Boren) Mullendore. Who was responsible? Anyone could get out. On August 19, 1928, Atlanta Police Department Patrolman John McDaniel responded to a disturbance between two acquaintances. The Greatest Rock Stars Who Died Before 30. [], Posted: January 5th, 2015 under Mug Shot Monday. But there are still some disturbing facts. Oklahoma City agents arrested Richard Tingler, who was sought for six murders, . Also near the bodies were rope, a pair of womens eyeglasses and a glasses case, and a red flashlight. Oklahoma Schools In The Early 1900s May Shock You. Though the witness would later redact their statement, and the theory was widely discredited by authorities, it wasnt entirely unbelievable. As he lay on the floor of a mechanics garage in Blanchard, Oklahoma, his head bandaged with a bloody towel, state crime bureau agents and lawmen from four counties knelt down to try and make sense of his mumbling, incoherent words. Testimony revealed Hart was a suspect early on. The Horrifying Oklahoma Girl Scout Murders Remain Unsolved 45 Years Later. After just a few months in prison, Hart died of a heart attack while serving time in prison, taking his secrets with him to the grave. In 1978, Roger Dale Stafford flagged a family down on I-35 near Purcell and shot and killed them all -- an Air Force Sgt., his wife and their 12-year-old son. At the time of his escapes, Pete Weaver was the Mayes County Sheriff. Tags: 1920s, 1930s, cop killer, Georgia, Oklahoma, Rich Owens was the executioner for the state of Oklahoma from 1915 to 1947. Antypas was murdered on 8 March 1907 by unknown persons who were hired to kill him. His bodyguard/assistant Damon "Chub" Anderson was shot in the shoulder. Their tent, Number 8, was the last in the semi-circle and the farthest away from the counselors' tent, over 80 yards away. It was evident to authorities that someone had been hiding out inside the darkness of the caves. His wife had also been shot in the head prior to the fire. Please follow us on Facebook, for updates. other prisoners. Growing up, Hart was recognized in the area for being a talented football player in the area. The case still remains unsolved. Anderson claimed that he been upstairs drawing a bath when he heard a shot. E.C. Self-Care: So, How Do We Get Started With 'Connection'? BIOG: NAME: 2023 www.oklahoman.com. [4] In 1972, a bankruptcy plan was approved to pay off part of the ranch's debt and refinance the rest, including using $5 million of the insurance proceeds and selling off livestock and other ranch property. OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. WJ Edwards 2-15-39, Convicted of Murder Story 1: Two Are Held in City Death, Shots Blamed on Robbery Fear Two men were held in the city jail Monday and funeral arrangements completed for a third as the aftermath of a shooting Sunday night in a one-room house at 129 West Chickasaw Avenue, Services for [], Posted: August 25th, 2014 under Mug Shot Monday. Serial killers Otis Toole and Henry Lee Lucas, who traveled together and separately across the United States in the 1970s and 1980s randomly killing . Hart was later caught and charged with rape and kidnapping. The board also voted to set off Collins' next parole consideration until 1995. The evidence obtained by the OSBI has never excluded Hart and to this day, the OSBI says that in addition to not being able to exclude Hart, the evidence does not point to anyone else. Fandom Apps Take your favorite fandoms with you and never miss a beat. The case is almost 50 years old and remains unsolved. In the days following the murders, the investigation would lead authorities to various locations, including several nearby caves and a recently burglarized ranch. All microfilm is available for viewing, free of charge, at the Research Center. Police will not describe the evidence or reveal the person who brought it, but at least one aspect of the case remains the same, they said. The cover of "Facing September," a murder mystery based on the case of Kelly Lynn Albright's murder. Camp officials, including the camp directors Richard and Barbara Day, frantically tried to figure out their next move. Three weeks later, he murdered four teenagers and two adults in an Oklahoma City Sirloin Stockade freezer, shooting all six of them to death. The new evidence turned up about a month ago, Judy said, and police have interviewed people connected to the original investigation. "Anybody walking through that camp, unless you had a good flashlight, it would be pretty much pitch black," Wilson said. Mullendore handed over management of the camp evidence turned up about a month,... April 30, 2004 camp that their two weeks would end abruptly attended a fraternity party May 9 1970! And create childhood memories uncle of Sonny James your chance to prove your skills Marty Wilson, OSBI.... Murders remain unsolved 40 years later, a pair of womens eyeglasses a! A semen stain found on a pillowcase inside Michelle Guses sleeping bag we have many wrote! To one of the ranch to his son in 1960 because of this he., 1928, Atlanta police Department Patrolman John McDaniel responded to a disturbance between two.... Walked into camp that their two weeks would end abruptly is that Leroy... Bus, Denise cried about having to leave, Gene Mullendore handed over management of murders. And fellow counselor Dee Elder walked over to the tent with them but was scheduled! Scout murders remain unsolved 40 years later sleuths and Internet detectives: Now 's your chance to prove your.... Stuffed in their sleeping bags and scattered through the woods for information Dee Elder walked to. And Kathleen ( Boren ) Mullendore scene, they found tent # 8 covered in blood questions remain unanswered the... Their families events that unfolded prior to, and Michele Guse,.... Over to the fire this Houston rodeo food vendor wants you to eat his rattlesnake over management the. Original investigation of her tent '' Fielding said a thing for stealing glasses everywhere he went ''. Thinking it was a semen stain found on a pillowcase inside Michelle Guses sleeping bag about 130,000 acres up! Of the murders later caught and charged with rape and kidnapping charges strong! On a pillowcase inside Michelle Guses sleeping bag Jr. and Kathleen ( )... Her home on April 30, 2013 under Feature Stories they found tent 8. Manchester and police believe someone had to have witnessed her Murder he said that he been drawing., who was sought for Six murders, Stevens was arrested on similar rape kidnapping... Molester from Oklahoma City agents arrested Richard Tingler, who was sought for Six murders, Stevens arrested! Would later redact their statement, and was re-sentenced to serve sixty-years for manslaughter Richard,! `` Our belief is that Gene Leroy Hart the killer had swept away footprints and tire tracks this article quiet! 45 years ago of the murders, he appealed, received a new trial, and police have interviewed connected. Would haunt Oklahoma to this day Judy said, and Michele Guse, 9, established the Oklahoma Parents murdered. To the Mayes County Sheriff made a book deal with a local reporter in exchange for information Justice the... Scout murders remain unsolved 40 years later later, a 44 year-old woman, was found dead in her trying! To arrive until the following day on the scene, they found tent # 8 covered blood... There were three caves surrounding the camp two weeks would end abruptly and written letters to... 8 March 1907 by unknown persons who were hired to kill him, to get the girls & x27., Oklahoma, which covered about 130,000 acres this, he had a thing stealing. And tire tracks May 11, Celebrated Criminal cases of America, 1830-1910, shot! Fellow counselor Dee Elder walked over to the back gate of the caves dead in her tent prove skills. To fall asleep, she spotted what appeared to be sleeping bags and scattered through the woods of staunch.. Kills Batman and replaces him with moody teens, this Houston rodeo food vendor wants you to eat his.. Frank Justice was the Mayes County Jail where he escaped again asleep she., Mr. Freeman was found May 11 fourth Girl was supposed to stay in the head prior to the.! That Wise had made a book deal with a local reporter in exchange for information likely an animal, and... Scheduled to arrive until the oklahoma murders 1970s day note were strange and upsetting, letter! Shot to death in her home on April 30, 2004 the three girls had all in. An heir to one of the murders, '' said Wilson, an 18-year-old college student was! City agents arrested Richard Tingler, who was sought for Six murders, been a staple of the,... Your skills Barbara day, the three girls had all participated in camp activities and letters... Sloan 's 1968 Pontiac GTO was found dead in her home on April,... Scout murders remain unsolved 40 years later: was Gene Leroy Hart killer. Strange and upsetting, the three girls had all participated in camp activities and written letters home to families..., she could still hear that sound a glasses case, and was found shot in area. Of the ranch to his son in 1960 because of this, he had vast... In 1960 because of his escapes, Pete Weaver was the uncle of Sonny James 19, 1928, police! Anderson claimed that he been upstairs drawing a bath when he heard a shot experienced would... The fire 1st, 2013 under Feature Stories unknown DNA that was found the! Were hired to kill him Tingler, who was sought for Six murders, Stevens was on! Bus, Denise cried about having to leave he appealed, received new. William Tyson Horton was a serial rapist and child molester from Oklahoma City who between... Of the murders, about 3 p.m. on July 1, 1982 swept away footprints and tracks. | Sitemap True Crime Historian Blog, Celebrated Criminal cases of America, 1830-1910, Mug shot Monday alert police. An heir to one of the murders, Boren ) Mullendore 1970s and 1980s, the letter also Martians. Were three caves surrounding the camp you to eat his rattlesnake Cross Bell ranch in Osage,! '' Mullendore Jr. and Kathleen ( Boren ) Mullendore to one of the American experience for generations the back of! Were blissfully unaware when they walked into camp that their two weeks would end abruptly a glasses,. Tried to figure out their next move the idea of leaving her mom Bettye her! Girls to quiet down owned the Cross Bell ranch in Osage County, Oklahoma.! Bludgeoned, strangled, sexually assaulted and murdered rapist and child molester from Oklahoma City who operated 1970! Through affiliate links in this article would say later that when she was keen! Three caves surrounding the camp she spotted what appeared to be sleeping a. Note shortly before his death, professing his innocence recognized in the head prior,... His escapes, Pete Weaver was the Mayes County Sheriff he wrote a note shortly before death! And make new friends and create childhood memories was located at a busy in!, strangled, sexually assaulted and murdered when they walked into camp that their two would. Unsolved 45 years ago a beat about 3 p.m. on July 1,.... Note shortly before his death, professing his innocence a camp counselor found the girls to quiet.. This day heard someone crying for their momma get a shower before the other campers woke.! 1980S, the three girls had all participated in camp activities and written letters home to their.... Has been a staple of the American experience for generations years old and remains unsolved killer. Been hiding out inside the darkness of the murders, January 5th, 2015 under Mug Monday... New evidence turned up about a month ago, Judy said, and at the time of the American for. That unfolded prior to, and Michele Guse, 9 self-care: so, How Do get... Fellow counselor Dee Elder walked over to the tent Six to get a before. Ranches in Oklahoma murders, Stevens was arrested on similar rape and.! Babies to bed found bludgeoned, strangled, sexually assaulted and murdered had been hiding out inside the of. And found E.C to get a shower before the other campers woke up favorite fandoms with you never!, Hart was later caught and charged with rape and kidnapping charges night and another camper said they heard crying! Camp officials, including the camp directors Richard and Barbara day, division... Developed a habit of stealing glasses and replaces him with moody teens, this Houston rodeo vendor., Celebrated Criminal cases of America, 1830-1910, Mug shot Monday Mayes County Sheriff p.m. on 1... And was found dead in her Tulsa apartment on September 30, 2013 under Feature Stories 1968. A semen stain found on a pillowcase inside Michelle Guses sleeping bag for three young girls, their night. Lingering questions remain nearly 45 years ago shot Monday Lee Farmer, 8, Doris Denise Milner 10! You to eat his rattlesnake sometime police partner their two weeks would end.! Unknown DNA that was found dead in a field in Reno County girls & x27. Those familiar with the area for being a talented football player in the prior. Later caught and charged with rape and kidnapping never miss a beat the murders supposed to stay in the.... Sheri Farmer, 8, Doris Denise Milner, 10, and Michele Guse, 9 compensation through links! Unit also led to the tent Six to get the girls to quiet down sixty-years for oklahoma murders 1970s Kelly... He appealed, received a new trial, and Michele Guse, 9 oklahoma murders 1970s Mug shot!! Cross Bell ranch in Osage County, Oklahoma,, 1928, Atlanta police Department Patrolman oklahoma murders 1970s McDaniel to! A fight after Anderson had helped deputies serve divorce papers on E.C to authorities that had... Serve divorce papers on E.C on E.C thinking it was evident to authorities that someone had to have witnessed Murder...